Tuesday, October 21, 2008

"A Companion Picture" and "A Fellow of Delicacy"

In these chapters, Stryver tells two men of his plans to ask Lucie to marry him. Each man in the pair gives a different type of reaction, giving insight into their personalities. When Carton is told the news, he begins to drink rapidly, and when asked if he was astonished replies "Why should I be astonished?" and if he approved, "Why should I not approve?" (145). On the other hand, after Mr. Lorry is informed of Stryver's decision, he gives his opinion to the man, telling him that it may not be such a good idea, saying, "it might be painful for you to find yourself mistaken" (152). Through these passages we can see that Carton is less likely to voice his opinion, although we know for sure that he has a very strong one since he started to drink so fervently, and because he was one of Miss Manette's suitors earlier in the book. Since he does not show this view by speaking, we can then assume he likes to keep his emotions to himself. By not interfering, he also shows he doesn't want to get involved in the situation. Mr. Lorry is the opposite, using his words instead of actions. He starts to show his true character of being opinionated and wanting to speak his mind that exists behind the facade he puts on for Tellson's. We see that there is much more to him than just a man of business working at a bank. This straightforwardness eventually leads to Stryver deciding not to propose, so Mr. Lorry's methods are much more effective, which is not a surprise.

No comments: